+% Proposal: if the paper presents a new idea, what, in a nutshell, is it?
+
+% Evidence: Support for claims - Theorems? Case studies? Simulations?
+
+% Benchmarks? Does evidence address issues needed to support claims?
+
+% Shoulders of giants...: what previous research does this work build on? What
+% are the key underlying theoretical ideas? Software infrastructure?
+
+% Impact: has this work been influential? When later research papers cite it,
+% what contribution is being referred to?
+
+% Writing: analyse the writing
+
+% Discussion points: end with questions which you think should arise
+